What Items to Avoid at Goodwill Outlets (And Why They’re Risky)
Want to get the best value at the bins? Then knowing what items to avoid at Goodwill Outlets is just as important as knowing what to grab. While it’s tempting to pick up everything that looks cheap, not all items are safe, clean, or worth your money. From recalled baby gear to moldy books, there are certain things you should never buy — no matter how low the price. This guide breaks it all down, so you can thrift smart and avoid common mistakes.
1. Old or Recalled Baby Items
Strollers, car seats, cribs, and high chairs may look fine, but they can be outdated or recalled, making them unsafe. Many of these products must meet modern safety standards. If they don’t, they could be dangerous to use.
Instead: Buy new or check recall lists on CPSC.gov.
2. Broken Electronics or Devices Without Cords
At Goodwill Outlets, many electronics are tossed into bins without testing. Some may not work, while others are missing essential parts. Without a power cord or battery, there’s no way to tell if the item functions.
Instead: Stick to electronics you can test before buying or purchase from goodwilloutlets.us where condition is often listed.
3. Worn-Out or Damaged Shoes
Yes, you can find great shoes at the bins — but be careful. If they have cracked soles, missing insoles, or visible mold, skip them. These issues make shoes uncomfortable or even unhealthy to wear. If you’re hoping to score quality footwear, check out our guide on things you should always buy at the Goodwill Outlet to know what’s truly worth grabbing.
Instead: Look for lightly used pairs that still have strong soles and intact interiors.
4. Used Mattresses or Pillows
Even if they look clean, pillows and mattresses can hide bed bugs, allergens, or odors. These are items you sleep on — it’s not worth the risk.
Instead: Buy new or use washable covers on thrifted cushions you trust.
5. Moldy or Water-Damaged Books
Books at the bins often come in bulk. Flip through them before buying. Musty smells, warped pages, or water stains are signs of mold, which can spread to other books at home. For safer picks, browse our tips on how to shop Goodwill Outlet like a pro — it includes advice on what to check before you toss anything in your cart.
Instead: Pick clean, dry books. Children’s books and recent novels are usually safe finds.
6. Chipped or Cracked Dishes
Glassware and dishes may look like a bargain, but chips and cracks make them unsafe. They can harbor bacteria or break easily during use.
Instead: Search for sturdy, undamaged kitchenware — especially Pyrex, Corelle, or vintage sets in good shape.
7. Opened Beauty Products or Toiletries
Lotions, makeup, and shampoos sometimes show up at Goodwill Outlets — but used or half-open products are unsafe. They can contain bacteria or be expired.
Instead: Only buy sealed, unused products with a valid expiration date.
8. Outdated Media (VHS Tapes, Burned DVDs)
Unless you’re a collector, skip media that’s scratched, blank, or in obsolete formats. Many DVDs and CDs at the bins are scratched or unreadable.
Instead: Choose newer titles in great condition, or search for sealed copies you can resell.
9. Items with Strong Odors or Stains
Smell items before tossing them in your cart. Items that reek of smoke, mildew, or chemicals can be hard to clean. These odors often don’t go away — even after multiple washes.
Instead: Stick to items that pass the sniff test and look clean overall.
10. Tools with Rust or Missing Parts
Used tools can be a great deal, but avoid those with heavy rust, frayed cords, or missing pieces. They may be unsafe or unusable.
Instead: Look for clean, solid tools with all parts and no corrosion.
Final Thoughts
While shopping at Goodwill Outlets can lead to great finds, it’s just as important to know what items to avoid at Goodwill Outlets. From damaged electronics to moldy books and unsafe baby gear, skipping these problem items can protect your health, home, and wallet.
With a sharp eye and smart choices, you’ll still walk away with amazing deals — just without the risk.
